Disney vs. the Real Story of Mulan Rap Song with Compare and Contrast Worksheets

Disney vs. the Real Story of Mulan Rap Song with Compare and Contrast Worksheets


Disney versus history – another comparison. “Disney’s version of Mulan, how is it different from the original Chinese folktale?” is the question. Do they contrast, or are they similar in content? It’s not a Disney movie. It’s Chinese history –
historical tradition, connecting a legend with a dynasty. A daughter substituting for her father in a war brings honor to China, becoming legend evermore. Verse one, Disney’s version of Mulan:
In the movie, a teen girl named Mulan takes her father’s place in the army. The parents are unaware of where their daughter
is, giving them a scare finding out that she enlisted. Dressed as a man, Mulan takes her father’s
military notice, stealing his armor and sword, leaving without any notice. Mulan spends no more than months in the Chinese army. Before the war is won comes the end of her
deception. Injured severely in battle, Mulan needs attention,
so the army medics discover that she is a woman. Expelled from the military because of her
trickery, later, Mulan returns with more tricks, leading them to victory. Despite her lies, Mulan maintains friendship
with army allies. With the sword of the defeated foe, she is
rewarded. Mulan even receives a position from the Emperor
working in his palace. Now, with gifts in hand, she returns to see
her parents. It’s not a Disney movie. It’s Chinese history –
historical tradition, connecting a legend with a dynasty. A daughter substituting for her father in a war brings honor to China, becoming legend evermore. It’s not a Disney movie. It’s Chinese history –
historical tradition, connecting a legend with a dynasty. A daughter substituting for her father in a war brings honor to China, becoming legend evermore. Verse two, the traditional Chinese story:
In the ballad, Mulan’s parents agree to her joining the army. To save her elderly father, she disguises as a man and is given the family’s sword for the
battle at hand. Ten years into the war, Mulan inspires the
troops, joining the battle in women’s clothing, stunning the soldiers with the truth. Later, she returns home, remaining friendly
with the army. Refusing reward, she just wants to see her family. Around the fifth century, the “Ballad of Mulan”
was born to encourage the defeated empire of China. A poem about a warrior woman gave hope to an army. Retold throughout the ages, Mulan is legendary. It’s not a Disney movie. It’s Chinese history –
historical tradition, connecting a legend with a dynasty. A daughter substituting for her father in a war brings honor to China, becoming legend evermore.

, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

About Author

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *